Goevry World Shopping Magazine

Top Menu

  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contacts
  • UK
  • DE

Main Menu

  • Travel & Lifestyle
  • Fashion
  • Health & Beauty
  • Science & Tech
  • Gift Guides
  • Buying Guides
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contacts
  • UK
  • DE

logo

Goevry World Shopping Magazine

  • Travel & Lifestyle
    • Goditi la natura, il comfort e l'avventura con hu Village Holidays

      October 26, 2026
      0
    • Encuentra el seguro de viaje adecuado para tu próxima aventura

      October 25, 2026
      0
    • Scopri le avventure sulle isole del Mediterraneo con Ferryhopper

      October 25, 2026
      0
    • Enjoy Great Food and Fun at The Top Hat Restaurant & Bar

      October 25, 2026
      0
    • Discover Tenerife: Your Guide to an Unforgettable Island Getaway

      October 23, 2026
      0
    • Visitas al One World Observatory Group: experiencias inolvidables sobre la ciudad de ...

      October 22, 2026
      0
    • Discover Boston from Above with an Unforgettable View Boston Experience

      October 22, 2026
      0
    • Avanti Travel Insurance: Find the Right Single-Trip Cover for Your Next Holiday

      October 12, 2026
      0
    • Avanti Travel Insurance: Cover Options for Your Next Trip

      October 12, 2026
      0
  • Fashion
    • Descubre las gafas de sol deportivas Eagle Eyes® para rendir al máximo ...

      November 8, 2026
      0
    • Descubre los elegantes bolsos de mujer de Mario Hernández

      November 4, 2026
      0
    • Magliette da uomo ufficiali F**K – Comfort quotidiano e stile moderno

      November 3, 2026
      0
    • Discover Stylish Women's Skirts at The Edit Boutique

      November 2, 2026
      0
    • Celebrate Your Team Pride with Official New York Liberty Merchandise

      October 26, 2026
      0
    • Bolsos unisex de Mario Hernández: el estilo se une a la practicidad ...

      October 10, 2026
      0
    • Camisetas de mujer de Mario Hernández: la comodidad para el día a ...

      October 10, 2026
      0
    • Al diavolo le gonne da acqua: scelte alla moda per l’estate e ...

      October 6, 2026
      0
    • Discover FYTOO’s New Men’s Arrivals – Up to 30% Off

      September 19, 2026
      0
  • Health & Beauty
    • Protect Your Cat’s Health with Petgevity Lifetime Insurance

      November 16, 2026
      0
    • Goditi una doccia rinfrescante con i gel doccia L’Occitane

      November 13, 2026
      0
    • Travel with Confidence: Avanti Pre-Existing Medical Conditions Travel Insurance

      November 4, 2026
      0
    • Hume Body Check: Gewinnen Sie Einblicke in Ihre Gesundheit – mit einem ...

      October 26, 2026
      0
    • Supporting Hope Through the Middle East Emergency Appeal

      October 22, 2026
      0
    • L’Occitane en Provence: Trattamenti nutrienti per la pelle secca

      October 6, 2026
      0
    • Compare Travel Insurance Easily for Every Journey

      September 24, 2026
      0
    • Proteggi la tua salute con le polizze AXA Partners Italia

      September 24, 2026
      0
    • Hume-Gesundheitsempfehlungsprogramm: Teilen Sie Ihre Gesundheitserfahrungen und verdienen Sie Prämien

      September 22, 2026
      0
  • Science & Tech
    • Mejora Buró: Asesoramiento financiero y apoyo para la gestión de la deuda

      October 27, 2026
      0
    • Mejora Buró: Asesoramiento financiero para la mejora de la solvencia crediticia y ...

      October 27, 2026
      0
    • Ricarica dei veicoli elettrici A2A: verso un futuro più sostenibile

      October 23, 2026
      0
    • A2A Illuminazione Pubblica: illuminazione intelligente e sostenibile per le città moderne

      October 23, 2026
      0
    • Teleriscaldamento A2A: energia efficiente per una vita confortevole

      September 29, 2026
      0
    • 3D-Scanner für präzise digitale Erfassung und professionelle Ergebnisse

      September 13, 2026
      0
    • Ratgeber zum Kauf von UV-Druckern: Finden Sie den perfekten Drucker für Ihre ...

      August 8, 2026
      0
    • Entdecken Sie intelligente Software und kreative Ideen für den 3D-Druck mit eufyMake

      August 2, 2026
      0
    • Step Into the World of Secrets, Challenges, and Spy-Inspired Discovery with SPYSCAPE

      July 1, 2026
      0
  • Gift Guides
    • A Social Night Out in London: Monopoly Lifesized Brings Competition to ...

      April 16, 2026
      0
    • Create Lasting Memories with CEWE Photo Book: Your Personalized Keepsake from Boots ...

      May 8, 2025
      0
    • Farrar & Tanner: Luxury and Bespoke Gifts for Every Occasion

      March 25, 2025
      0
    • Tommee Tippee Soothers: The Perfect Blend of Comfort, Style, and Practicality for ...

      March 13, 2025
      0
    • Indulge at the Pinnacle of Private Luxury with Je Joue

      March 8, 2025
      0
    • Get Closer to Your Favorite Stars With Memmo.me’s Exclusive Celebrity Video Messages

      February 25, 2025
      0
    • Waterford Crystal – Mastering the Art of Fine Glassware and Elegant Home ...

      February 15, 2025
      0
    • Discover the World of Exclusive Whiskies with The Scotch Malt Whisky Society

      February 8, 2025
      0
    • Embark on an Exclusive Whisky Journey with The Scotch Malt Whisky Society

      February 8, 2025
      0
  • Buying Guides
    • New York Yankees: Tickets, Games and the Yankee Stadium Experience

      September 29, 2026
      0
    • Elevate Your Game with Premium Golf Balls and Exclusive Deals at Discount ...

      April 17, 2025
      0
    • Aatu’s Premium Dog and Cat Food Delivers High-Quality Nutrition with Natural Ingredients

      April 14, 2025
      0
    • AATU Offers Premium Pet Food Made with Fresh Meat and Natural Ingredients ...

      April 9, 2025
      0
    • Discover the Best Boxsets from Townsendmusic

      February 21, 2025
      0
    • Transform Your Garden into a Bird Haven with These Must-Haves

      January 10, 2025
      0
    • Discovering Unique Whisky Flavours: A Journey of Taste and Tradition

      January 10, 2025
      0
    • Stress-Free Parenting Explore Tommee Tippee’s Range of Baby Care Innovations

      December 26, 2024
      0
    • TOMMEE TIPPEE Innovative Designs for Happy, Healthy Babies and Stress-Free Parents

      December 12, 2024
      0
  • Descubre el ordenador para videojuegos ideal para disfrutar de la mejor experiencia de juego

  • Descubre el bienestar diario con los suplementos en polvo de Aldous

  • Protect Your Cat’s Health with Petgevity Lifetime Insurance

  • Experience the Ultimate Real-Life Monopoly Adventure

  • Entdecken Sie bei 3DPrima UV-Drucklösungen für kreative Projekte

  • Goditi una doccia rinfrescante con i gel doccia L’Occitane

  • Erfrischende Fruchtsäfte und köstliche Getränke für jeden Anlass

  • Descubre las gafas de sol deportivas Eagle Eyes® para rendir al máximo en tu día a día

Science & Tech
Home›Science & Tech›Lessons from Afghanistan for NATO’s new Ukraine command

Lessons from Afghanistan for NATO’s new Ukraine command

By admin1
July 7, 2024
1398
0
Share:

[ad_1]

At the Washington summit this week, NATO plans to launch a new command to lead the coordination of security assistance and training to Ukraine. This would be the alliance’s first major new operation since the end of the mission in Afghanistan, and, according to some reports, is intended to reduce risk to Ukraine if support from the United States were to diminish.

However, one of the clear lessons from Afghanistan is that NATO is unable to execute operations without U.S. leadership. Ultimately, the level of Western support for Ukraine—and its effectiveness—will rise and fall based on U.S. policy and commitment, just as it did in Afghanistan. A U.S. policy of support to Ukraine remains the biggest lever to stop Russia’s aggression and ensure Ukrainian victory.

During 20 years in Afghanistan, NATO institutions’ most important contribution was coordinating allied and partner military personnel support. Because of caps on total U.S. personnel in country, contributions in areas such as force protection for NATO member states and partners such as Georgia allowed the U.S. to deploy more higher-end forces and thereby increase overall mission effectiveness. At the peak in January 2011, non-U.S. participants made up 42,000 of the 132,000 deployed, while by the end of the mission in 2021, there were 7,100 allied and partner troops and 2,500 U.S. personnel in country. Allies and partners also suffered a heavy burden of casualties even with smaller numbers of total personnel: 1,144 killed in the war as compared to 2,465 from the United States.  

NATO also contributed financially, but significantly less than the United States: the NATO Afghan National Army Trust Fund contributed a total of $3.4 billion from 2007 to 2021, while obligations from the U.S. Afghanistan Security Force Fund totaled $74.7 billion from 2005 to 2020. Still, the Trust Fund demonstrates how NATO can provide a trusted venue for non-NATO partner countries to contribute—South Korea donated $319 million, for example. It also shows how NATO processes and standards enable small nations’ efforts to build into larger contributions. 

While NATO formally uses the decision process of unanimity, U.S. policies dominated the trajectory of NATO’s mission in Afghanistan. At each critical juncture of the mission—the early days after the 9/11 attacks, the expansion of the mission in 2006, the 2009-2011 surge, and the final departure in 2020-2021—the record of debate followed the same pattern: The U.S tended to inform allies of decisions, which then became alliance policy, rather than bringing allies into the decision-making process.

Perhaps the most striking example was in the 2020 U.S.-Taliban agreement, where the U.S. committed to withdraw allied and partner troops—even though NATO was not a party to the agreement. Key allies, including the UK, criticized the U.S. policy, and others might have preferred to continue the mission. But as Secretary General Stoltenberg later explained, allies’ decision to agree to the departure “reflects the reality that when the United States decided to end its presence in Afghanistan…there was no willingness from other European allies, Canada, or the partner nations, to replace or to fill in after the United States.” 

The biggest lesson therefore for Ukraine is that NATO, at least in its current configuration, cannot conduct substantial operations in the absence of policy leadership from the United States. There are several factors that limit the non-U.S. allies’ influence, but greater and more focused U.S. resource investment is probably the most important. Even though overall European contributions to Ukraine exceed those of the United States when budgetary and humanitarian assistance are included, U.S. military assistance exceeds that of all EU members combined.  

European members of NATO have struggled to provide Ukraine with sufficient military assistance due to slow progress in expanding their defense industries. NATO’s ability to contribute military forces as it did in Afghanistan is also less relevant in Ukraine, where the most important lever is probably materiel assistance. Some allies have provided new capabilities before the United States, such as the UK and France providing Storm Shadow and SCALP long range missiles. However, Germany’s decision to delay sending Leopard tanks until the United States provided Abrams illustrates how U.S. policy remains a key limiting factor.

Even if European countries were able to step up with more materiel, their dependence on the U.S. military goes deeper than procurement budgets. The United States has often launched simultaneous missions with more expansive mandates side-by-side with NATO-led operations. After 2014, for example, the NATO-led Resolute Support gave up its combat role, but U.S. Forces-Afghanistan, led by a dual-hatted U.S. general, continued to have a combat mission. 

In Ukraine, the U.S.-led Security Assistance Group will probably maintain a more involved operational role overseeing “the full-spectrum of security assistance” than a NATO command focused on coordinating training and sustainment. In planning new operations and strategies, the smaller policy and planning offices of the European defense ministries also face coordination challenges, and cannot match the U.S. Defense Department’s depth of expertise.

The experience in Afghanistan does show the benefits a NATO-led operation can provide. NATO is uniquely good at coordinating security assistance from many countries. NATO’s deliberate decision-making rhythm may also bring a longer-term perspective. U.S. policymakers set overly high expectations for the 2023 Ukrainian counteroffensive, in part because of accurate concerns about declining U.S. support. If NATO can bring a longer-term approach, that would be welcome.

NATO’s new effort on Ukraine will hopefully lead to larger and more coherent support. But the idea that NATO can somehow substitute for U.S. disengagement is flawed, as the record of NATO’s engagement in Afghanistan clearly demonstrates. As one joke goes, the acronym NATO also stands for “need Americans to operate.” Ensuring an ambitious and coherent U.S. policy and strategy to support Ukraine’s victory remains as important as ever. 

Andrew Radin is a senior political scientist at RAND, a nonprofit, nonpartisan research institution. From 2018 to 2020, he served as a country director for Afghanistan in the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Policy.



[ad_2]

Source link

Tagsarmycanadafacefacebookfallfrancegermanygoodkoreanewpartyrussiashowthetraininguk
Previous Article

Carlos Alcaraz vs. Ugo Humbert FREE LIVE ...

Next Article

When Students Are Absent, Do Their Relationships ...

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Related articles More from author

  • Health & Beauty

    Dear Abby: I’m no longer invited to family celebrations or holidays. I am heartbroken and lonely.

    October 31, 2023
    By admin1
  • All

    Get your remaining marketing ROI for 2022

    September 14, 2022
    By admin1
  • Health & Beauty

    what it means to go back to school

    August 28, 2022
    By admin1
  • Health & Beauty

    Top federal health officials slam marijuana research barriers that have hindered research into opioid alternatives

    September 2, 2022
    By admin1
  • All

    NetNewsLedger – Boost Revenue with Digital Marketing

    September 7, 2022
    By admin1
  • All

    Cook with Confidence: Discover Delicious, Sustainable Meals with Gousto’s Meal Kits

    November 19, 2024
    By admin1

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You may interested

  • Science & Tech

    ‘Night of the Living Dead’ Exhibit Adds to Carnegie Science Center’s Miniature Railroad and Village

  • Science & Tech

    NASA’s DART mission successfully hits an asteroid

  • Science & Tech

    School board delays first review of new history, social science standards amid public outcry

Search

Categories

  • All (1,243)
  • Animal Food (23)
  • Books & Novels (24)
  • Buying Guides (21)
  • Buying Guides (32)
  • Donation and Services (7)
  • Export Test (21)
  • Fashion (1,776)
  • Fashis (1)
  • Fitness & Health (21)
  • Food & Drinks (28)
  • Gift Guides (23)
  • Gift Guides (52)
  • Health & Beauty (1,634)
  • Health & Beauty (22)
  • Home&Living (242)
  • Marketing & Safety Solutions (5)
  • Mobility & Lifestyle (9)
  • Movies (3)
  • Non classifié(e) (2)
  • Nutritional Innovation (4)
  • Photo Gifts (1)
  • Price Comparison (1)
  • Science & Tech (1,353)
  • Science & Tech (1)
  • Sports (39)
  • Technology (201)
  • Travel & Lifestyle (1,786)
  • Travel & Lifestyle (17)
logo

Goevry is not just another run-of-the-mill magazine; it's a transformative journey that transcends the boundaries of traditional fashion publications. Our team of passionate experts, seasoned fashionistas, and visionary writers collaborate to curate a diverse range of thought-provoking features that delve into the very essence of style, culture, and identity.

  • Recent

  • Popular

  • Descubre el ordenador para videojuegos ideal para disfrutar de la mejor experiencia de juego

    By techsmillion
    November 17, 2026
  • Descubre el bienestar diario con los suplementos en polvo de Aldous

    By techsmillion
    November 16, 2026
  • A Homecoming Story, An Original Documentary Featuring Giannis Antetokounmpo

    By admin1
    January 17, 2024
  • US-Japan Science Communication & Policy Fellowship Network Program Fellow Announcement

    By admin1
    August 22, 2022

Follow us

  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contacts
©2024 Copyright Goevry | All Rights Reserved.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy policy