Goevry World Shopping Magazine

Top Menu

  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contacts
  • UK
  • DE

Main Menu

  • Travel & Lifestyle
  • Fashion
  • Health & Beauty
  • Science & Tech
  • Gift Guides
  • Buying Guides
  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contacts
  • UK
  • DE

logo

Goevry World Shopping Magazine

  • Travel & Lifestyle
    • Goditi la natura, il comfort e l'avventura con hu Village Holidays

      October 26, 2026
      0
    • Encuentra el seguro de viaje adecuado para tu próxima aventura

      October 25, 2026
      0
    • Scopri le avventure sulle isole del Mediterraneo con Ferryhopper

      October 25, 2026
      0
    • Enjoy Great Food and Fun at The Top Hat Restaurant & Bar

      October 25, 2026
      0
    • Discover Tenerife: Your Guide to an Unforgettable Island Getaway

      October 23, 2026
      0
    • Visitas al One World Observatory Group: experiencias inolvidables sobre la ciudad de ...

      October 22, 2026
      0
    • Discover Boston from Above with an Unforgettable View Boston Experience

      October 22, 2026
      0
    • Avanti Travel Insurance: Find the Right Single-Trip Cover for Your Next Holiday

      October 12, 2026
      0
    • Avanti Travel Insurance: Cover Options for Your Next Trip

      October 12, 2026
      0
  • Fashion
    • Descubre las gafas de sol deportivas Eagle Eyes® para rendir al máximo ...

      November 8, 2026
      0
    • Descubre los elegantes bolsos de mujer de Mario Hernández

      November 4, 2026
      0
    • Magliette da uomo ufficiali F**K – Comfort quotidiano e stile moderno

      November 3, 2026
      0
    • Discover Stylish Women's Skirts at The Edit Boutique

      November 2, 2026
      0
    • Celebrate Your Team Pride with Official New York Liberty Merchandise

      October 26, 2026
      0
    • Bolsos unisex de Mario Hernández: el estilo se une a la practicidad ...

      October 10, 2026
      0
    • Camisetas de mujer de Mario Hernández: la comodidad para el día a ...

      October 10, 2026
      0
    • Al diavolo le gonne da acqua: scelte alla moda per l’estate e ...

      October 6, 2026
      0
    • Discover FYTOO’s New Men’s Arrivals – Up to 30% Off

      September 19, 2026
      0
  • Health & Beauty
    • Protect Your Cat’s Health with Petgevity Lifetime Insurance

      November 16, 2026
      0
    • Goditi una doccia rinfrescante con i gel doccia L’Occitane

      November 13, 2026
      0
    • Travel with Confidence: Avanti Pre-Existing Medical Conditions Travel Insurance

      November 4, 2026
      0
    • Hume Body Check: Gewinnen Sie Einblicke in Ihre Gesundheit – mit einem ...

      October 26, 2026
      0
    • Supporting Hope Through the Middle East Emergency Appeal

      October 22, 2026
      0
    • L’Occitane en Provence: Trattamenti nutrienti per la pelle secca

      October 6, 2026
      0
    • Compare Travel Insurance Easily for Every Journey

      September 24, 2026
      0
    • Proteggi la tua salute con le polizze AXA Partners Italia

      September 24, 2026
      0
    • Hume-Gesundheitsempfehlungsprogramm: Teilen Sie Ihre Gesundheitserfahrungen und verdienen Sie Prämien

      September 22, 2026
      0
  • Science & Tech
    • Mejora Buró: Asesoramiento financiero y apoyo para la gestión de la deuda

      October 27, 2026
      0
    • Mejora Buró: Asesoramiento financiero para la mejora de la solvencia crediticia y ...

      October 27, 2026
      0
    • Ricarica dei veicoli elettrici A2A: verso un futuro più sostenibile

      October 23, 2026
      0
    • A2A Illuminazione Pubblica: illuminazione intelligente e sostenibile per le città moderne

      October 23, 2026
      0
    • Teleriscaldamento A2A: energia efficiente per una vita confortevole

      September 29, 2026
      0
    • 3D-Scanner für präzise digitale Erfassung und professionelle Ergebnisse

      September 13, 2026
      0
    • Ratgeber zum Kauf von UV-Druckern: Finden Sie den perfekten Drucker für Ihre ...

      August 8, 2026
      0
    • Entdecken Sie intelligente Software und kreative Ideen für den 3D-Druck mit eufyMake

      August 2, 2026
      0
    • Step Into the World of Secrets, Challenges, and Spy-Inspired Discovery with SPYSCAPE

      July 1, 2026
      0
  • Gift Guides
    • A Social Night Out in London: Monopoly Lifesized Brings Competition to ...

      April 16, 2026
      0
    • Create Lasting Memories with CEWE Photo Book: Your Personalized Keepsake from Boots ...

      May 8, 2025
      0
    • Farrar & Tanner: Luxury and Bespoke Gifts for Every Occasion

      March 25, 2025
      0
    • Tommee Tippee Soothers: The Perfect Blend of Comfort, Style, and Practicality for ...

      March 13, 2025
      0
    • Indulge at the Pinnacle of Private Luxury with Je Joue

      March 8, 2025
      0
    • Get Closer to Your Favorite Stars With Memmo.me’s Exclusive Celebrity Video Messages

      February 25, 2025
      0
    • Waterford Crystal – Mastering the Art of Fine Glassware and Elegant Home ...

      February 15, 2025
      0
    • Discover the World of Exclusive Whiskies with The Scotch Malt Whisky Society

      February 8, 2025
      0
    • Embark on an Exclusive Whisky Journey with The Scotch Malt Whisky Society

      February 8, 2025
      0
  • Buying Guides
    • New York Yankees: Tickets, Games and the Yankee Stadium Experience

      September 29, 2026
      0
    • Elevate Your Game with Premium Golf Balls and Exclusive Deals at Discount ...

      April 17, 2025
      0
    • Aatu’s Premium Dog and Cat Food Delivers High-Quality Nutrition with Natural Ingredients

      April 14, 2025
      0
    • AATU Offers Premium Pet Food Made with Fresh Meat and Natural Ingredients ...

      April 9, 2025
      0
    • Discover the Best Boxsets from Townsendmusic

      February 21, 2025
      0
    • Transform Your Garden into a Bird Haven with These Must-Haves

      January 10, 2025
      0
    • Discovering Unique Whisky Flavours: A Journey of Taste and Tradition

      January 10, 2025
      0
    • Stress-Free Parenting Explore Tommee Tippee’s Range of Baby Care Innovations

      December 26, 2024
      0
    • TOMMEE TIPPEE Innovative Designs for Happy, Healthy Babies and Stress-Free Parents

      December 12, 2024
      0
  • Descubre el ordenador para videojuegos ideal para disfrutar de la mejor experiencia de juego

  • Descubre el bienestar diario con los suplementos en polvo de Aldous

  • Protect Your Cat’s Health with Petgevity Lifetime Insurance

  • Experience the Ultimate Real-Life Monopoly Adventure

  • Entdecken Sie bei 3DPrima UV-Drucklösungen für kreative Projekte

  • Goditi una doccia rinfrescante con i gel doccia L’Occitane

  • Erfrischende Fruchtsäfte und köstliche Getränke für jeden Anlass

  • Descubre las gafas de sol deportivas Eagle Eyes® para rendir al máximo en tu día a día

Travel & Lifestyle
Home›Travel & Lifestyle›Are Two Teachers Better Than One?

Are Two Teachers Better Than One?

By admin1
September 13, 2022
634
0
Share:

[ad_1]

For nearly 50 years, special education law has mandated that students with disabilities be served in the “least restrictive environment” possible. This often takes the form of an inclusive classroom, or a general education classroom where students with disabilities learn alongside their non-disabled peers. In some cases, inclusive classrooms are co-taught by a general education teacher and a special education teacher who share planning and instructional responsibilities.

The logic behind co-teaching is intuitively appealing. Co-teaching reduces the student-teacher ratio, and the presence of two educators, each with distinctive expertise, should make it easier to connect students at a range of abilities to grade-level content. But how well does this approach actually work on the ground? Do students with disabilities benefit from the presence of an additional teacher in the classroom? And how does co-teaching affect learning for students without disabilities?

We examine a decade of test scores for students in Massachusetts, where co-teaching has experienced rapid growth, and find positive effects on academic achievement for students with and without disabilities in the years they are enrolled in co-taught classes. For students with disabilities, attending a co-taught classroom boosts test scores by 2.6 percent of a standard deviation in math and 1.6 percent of a standard deviation in reading, on average. For students without disabilities, test scores improve by 1.2 percent of a standard deviation in math, while reading scores are not affected. This is the case even though students without disabilities who never participate in a co-teaching classroom have higher math and reading scores, on average, than their peers who do.

At the same time, the gains we find are much smaller than those reported in prior research on co-teaching, which involved small samples and focused on short-term results (see “A Charter Boost for Special-Ed Students and English Learners,” research, Spring 2020). By contrast, our analysis looks at co-teaching as it is currently implemented across an entire state, tracks many students over a long period of time, and compares their rates of learning in years they did and did not attend a co-taught classroom.

While co-teaching is broadly popular among educators, its effectiveness for improving student outcomes depends on a key assumption—that the presence of a second adult results in more effective learning opportunities for students. Our findings appear more consistent with studies suggesting that just putting two teachers in the same room does not necessarily improve the quality of instruction students receive. In practice, co-teachers often do not work in the idealized way advocates of the approach recommend. Colocation does not necessarily cause effective collaboration.

Nonetheless, we do find some evidence of positive effects on student learning, even in an apparently less-than-perfect form. Whether the impact of co-teaching at such a scale can be improved by encouraging more consistent application of best practices in co-teaching is an important area for future research.

A Growing Share of Students in Co-Taught Classrooms (Figure 1)

Examining a Team Approach

To investigate the impact of co-teaching on academic achievement, we focus on Massachusetts, where the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education encourages co-teaching but has not adopted it as a statewide initiative. Our analysis uses administrative and test-score data from 2007–08 through 2017–18 for teachers and students enrolled in grades 3 through 8. This includes students’ demographic and socioeconomic data, students’ scores in math and reading on the Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System exams, teachers’ job-assignment classifications, and information on classroom assignments that link students with their teachers. We also consider state job-classification data, which identifies a “teacher” as an employee who provides instruction, learning experiences, and care to students during a particular period or in a given discipline and a “co-teacher” as a teacher who is equally responsible with another teacher for providing those same services.

In most cases, schools do not adopt co-teaching as a uniform policy that applies to all students, but rather offer a mixture of co-taught and single-teacher classrooms. We identify classrooms as co-taught based on multiple teachers being assigned to a single class in the same year. In 2011, less than 10 percent of Massachusetts schools educated students with disabilities in co-taught classrooms. By 2018, nearly 30 percent of schools educated at least some students with disabilities in co-taught classes.

The percentage of elementary- and middle-school students educated in co-teaching classrooms has grown sharply in recent years. Between 2011 and 2018, the percentage of all Massachusetts students educated in co-taught classrooms grew to 9.6 percent from 1.8 percent (see Figure 1). That growth was especially sharp in 5th-grade reading, where the percentage of co-taught students increased tenfold. The percentage of 5th-grade students with disabilities educated in co-taught classrooms grew to 26.8 percent from 3.1 percent. Among 5th graders without disabilities, the percentage in co-taught classrooms grew to 19.7 percent from 2.4 percent.

Importantly, most students who enter a co-taught class do not remain in that environment for the rest of their academic careers, but rather switch between co-taught and single-teacher classrooms over time. Because the goal of our study is to understand how attending a co-taught classroom instead of a classroom headed by a single teacher affects a student’s learning, we compare these “sometimes” co-taught students against themselves, both for students with and without disabilities. Our analysis considers whether a student earns higher or lower math and reading scores on state tests in years when they experience co-teaching compared to years when they are in a single-teacher classroom, controlling for characteristics of the student’s school.

Compared to students who never experience a co-taught classroom, students who are sometimes in a co-taught classroom—whether or not they have disabilities—are slightly more likely to be Hispanic, eligible for free or reduced-priced lunch, and have substantially lower math and reading scores, on average. Because decisions about offering co-teaching classrooms are made at the school level, these differences could stem from differences in the characteristics and leadership of schools that adopt co-teaching, as well as from schools’ decisions about which classrooms should use the approach.

Higher Test Scores in Co-Taught Classrooms for Students With and Without Disabilities (Figure 2)

Results

Attending a co-taught classroom improves test scores for students with and without disabilities, especially in math. Test scores for students with disabilities are 2.6 percent of a standard deviation higher in math and 1.6 percent of a standard deviation higher in reading when they are in co-taught classrooms, on average (see Figure 2). The positive impact on math achievement is larger in middle school than in the elementary grades, at 3.6 percent of a standard deviation compared to 1.4 percent in elementary grades. The impact on reading scores does not differ between elementary and middle school.

For students without disabilities, attending a co-taught classroom leads to a significant increase in math scores of 1.2 percent of a standard deviation. We find no significant effect of co-teaching on reading scores for students without disabilities. In looking separately at elementary- and middle-school grades, attending a co-taught classroom improves reading scores by 0.4 percent of a standard deviation in elementary school and reduces scores by 0.6 percent of a standard deviation in middle-school grades. However, these results are not statistically significant.

We also examine our results based on the characteristics of students in a class, including the percentage of students with disabilities in the class, and find little impact on the estimated effects of co-teaching. The estimated effect on reading in middle-school grades appears larger for females with disabilities at 2.8 percent of a standard deviation compared to 0.6 percent of a standard deviation for males with disabilities. We also find that the impact on reading scores in elementary grades is larger for Black students with disabilities compared to white students with disabilities, at 5.1 percent of a standard deviation versus 0.7 percent, respectively. However, neither of these differences is statistically significant. In looking across disability categories, we find positive effects from co-teaching within each disability type (see Figure 3).

We also look at the test scores for students with disabilities in co-taught classes compared to those for students in two types of single-teacher classes: special education and general education. We consider classes specific to special education if they are led by a special education teacher and predominately enroll students with disabilities. In no case do we find a significant difference between the effect of attending a special education versus a general education class with a single teacher. We interpret this as evidence that the effect of a student with disabilities attending a co-taught classroom is similar regardless of whether the student would otherwise be “mainstreamed” in a general education classroom without a co-teacher or enrolled in a self-contained special education class.

Effects of Co-Teaching on Test Scores by Disability Type (Figure 3)

More Than the Sum of Its Parts

We find that co-teaching has positive effects on academic achievement for students with and without disabilities, but the size of the impact on students with disabilities is substantially smaller than those reported in prior studies. Our results show that co-teaching can produce some benefits when implemented at scale, but they do not appear consistent with the enthusiasm that surrounds the practice in special education literature.

However, our analysis is limited to the effect of co-teaching on student test scores. Some of the most important justifications for moving students with disabilities into inclusive general education classrooms, which co-teaching can facilitate, are not academic. Inclusive environments like co-taught classrooms can foster tolerance and understanding among typically developing students, while also supporting students with disabilities to practice and develop social skills and build friendships with a broad group of peers.

That we analyze co-teaching within the context of a large public-school system is arguably both our study’s most valuable contribution and its most substantial limitation. Proponents of co-teaching might reasonably argue that the magnitude of our estimates is muted by schools and teachers that have moved students into classrooms where teachers are purportedly co-teaching but, in reality, do not apply the best practices necessary for co-teaching to be effective. Indeed, differences in the fidelity of implementation when co-teaching is considered across an entire state rather than within the context of a single school or classroom could at least partially explain why our findings are so much smaller than prior estimates. It is also primarily for this reason that, though co-teaching certainly reduces the adult-to-student ratio within a classroom, we caution against interpreting our results for the effect of co-teaching as the effect of substantially reducing class size.

Co-teachers Ann Renee Evans and Cassandra Hinson lead kindergarten storytime at Connerton Elementary in Land O' Lakes, Florida.
Co-teachers Ann Renee Evans and Cassandra Hinson lead kindergarten storytime at Connerton Elementary in Land O’ Lakes, Florida.

From a policy perspective, whether our findings support a decision to adopt co-teaching as an instructional model depends on the associated costs, which are thus far unknown. Transitioning to a co-teaching model almost certainly would require additional resources and personnel, which would appear to be a costly proposition. However, if considered within the broader topic of special education spending, using co-teaching to create inclusive general education classrooms may prove to be an efficient model. Prior research has found that serving students with disabilities in inclusive general education settings with team teaching costs less than sending students to standalone programs or classrooms.

School leaders and policymakers may consider whether the relevant comparison is between single-teacher and co-taught class costs, or between inclusive and non-inclusive special education programs. We encourage the field to continue building a more robust evidence base surrounding the services schools provide to the especially vulnerable group of students with disabilities.

Nathan Jones and Marcus A. Winters are associate professors at Boston University.

[ad_2]

Source link

Tagsbestblackeducationfloridafocusfreegainslooklunchmodelperfectschoolshareshowspringteamthetimewhitework
Previous Article

Tory Burch Spotlights Forgotten Pioneering American Fashion ...

Next Article

Health Calendar: September 13, 2022

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Related articles More from author

  • All

    Digital Marketing Executive – Altrincham Today

    September 13, 2022
    By admin1
  • Fashion

    The Timeless Elegance of Rachel Jackson’s Bracelet Collection: Adorn Your Wrist with Style

    January 3, 2025
    By admin1
  • Fashion

    Timeless Charles fashion

    September 9, 2022
    By admin1
  • Health & Beauty

    Adaptation Health joins Health Management Associates

    September 30, 2022
    By admin1
  • Science & Tech

    Will Earth ever leave the solar system?

    August 28, 2022
    By admin1
  • Fashion

    SCENE – SoMinn Fashion: Feeling like you have something to wear | Southern Min Scene

    August 22, 2022
    By admin1

You may interested

  • Science & Tech

    Science Center, Epcot, and Legacy of Legoland – Orlando Sentinel

  • Science & Tech

    What determines the color of hydrangeas?Experts analyze science

  • Science & Tech

    The Science of It: Eddy Currents

Search

Categories

  • All (1,243)
  • Animal Food (23)
  • Books & Novels (24)
  • Buying Guides (21)
  • Buying Guides (32)
  • Donation and Services (7)
  • Export Test (21)
  • Fashion (1,776)
  • Fashis (1)
  • Fitness & Health (21)
  • Food & Drinks (28)
  • Gift Guides (23)
  • Gift Guides (52)
  • Health & Beauty (1,634)
  • Health & Beauty (22)
  • Home&Living (242)
  • Marketing & Safety Solutions (5)
  • Mobility & Lifestyle (9)
  • Movies (3)
  • Non classifié(e) (2)
  • Nutritional Innovation (4)
  • Photo Gifts (1)
  • Price Comparison (1)
  • Science & Tech (1)
  • Science & Tech (1,353)
  • Sports (39)
  • Technology (201)
  • Travel & Lifestyle (1,786)
  • Travel & Lifestyle (17)
logo

Goevry is not just another run-of-the-mill magazine; it's a transformative journey that transcends the boundaries of traditional fashion publications. Our team of passionate experts, seasoned fashionistas, and visionary writers collaborate to curate a diverse range of thought-provoking features that delve into the very essence of style, culture, and identity.

  • Recent

  • Popular

  • Descubre el ordenador para videojuegos ideal para disfrutar de la mejor experiencia de juego

    By techsmillion
    November 17, 2026
  • Descubre el bienestar diario con los suplementos en polvo de Aldous

    By techsmillion
    November 16, 2026
  • A Homecoming Story, An Original Documentary Featuring Giannis Antetokounmpo

    By admin1
    January 17, 2024
  • Urban teenagers face unequal access to inclusive education

    By admin1
    September 25, 2022

Follow us

  • DMCA
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contacts
©2024 Copyright Goevry | All Rights Reserved.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy policy